Spencer was slightly tearful more because of her mothers pain than anything “so why don’t you accept Hayden being a lesbian?” this was something that Spencer had been wondering since she had come out to her mother, Paula looked up now talking directly to her daughter “Spence it’s not that I don’t accept her being gay its just that I can’t bring myself to accept her at all I always told my self when she was younger that I would grow to love her but the love never came she looks so much like her mother its like when I look at Hayden I don’t see her I see Harmony then the same betrayed feeling I had when she cheated came back you have you understand she’s a constant reminder of the girl that broke my heart” Paula looked pleadingly between her two silent children.

The youngest Carlin slowly started to shake her head as the information finally settled within her mind, “why did you keep her if she caused you such heart ache?” Glen spoke up suddenly startling his sister “we kept her because your father loved her like his own and because it was what Harmony wanted I could never deny her anything” again she began to sob, unknown to the group a deeply, emotionally and almost physically broken Hayden stood I the door frame listening to every word that was spoken she decided to speak up as anger flowed through her body “that’s why you never loved me because I look like my real mother, and all these years I thought It was because of my sexuality and behaviour I can’t believe how selfish you are” Glen quickly jumped to his mothers defence “how can you call her selfish when you’ve been trying to steal your sisters girlfriend now that is selfish” Spencer glared ay Hayden; Paula simply stared at the girl with no emotion apparent “oh no-No  she’s not my sister remember and Ashley wants me just you wait”.

Spencer had had it she leapt from her seat lunging at Hayden only Arthur was fast and restrained the furious little blonde by her arms, Hayden smirked leaning closer to Spencers ear so only she could hear “that won’t be last time I see MY Ashley naked Spence I guarantee it” Spencer squirmed hard trying to release herself from her fathers grip but failed instead she retaliated by shouting “you bitch she’s mine, I swear if you ever go by Ashley again I’ll make sure you don’t get up” she was seething she was it even scaring her parents as well as her brother; Hayden was also scared close to shaking in fact but refused to show it she again did what she always does when she is threatened she laughed then retreated to her room with another word.